Skip to content

Do Lawyers Lie About Settlements?

Michael Agruss

Written and Reviewed by Michael Agruss

  • Managing Partner and Personal Injury Lawyer at Mike Agruss Law.
  • Over 20 years of experience in Personal Injury.
  • Over 8000+ consumer rights cases settled.
  • Graduated from the University of Illinois Chicago School of Law: Juris Doctor, 2004.

When you have a personal injury claim, this is likely the first time in your life you’ve ever needed to hire a personal injury lawyer. As such, you may be a little uneasy. Your insurance company says they’ll give you a check for what your claim is worth. Should you accept it? If a Chicago personal injury lawyer tells you that your personal injury case is worth more, should you believe them? What exactly is a fair and reasonable settlement amount for what happened to you?

As well-reputed personal injury attorneys, we regularly work with injury victims who struggle with these questions. We’re not here to pressure you; we’re here to help. With this in mind, let’s dig further into the attorney client relationship and whether or not lawyers lie about settlements.

Lawyer Talking To A Patient

Do Lawyers Lie About Settlements? Unveiling the Truth

The subject of honesty in the legal profession, particularly in the context of settlement negotiations, raises critical ethical considerations. Personal injury attorneys are bound by a code of ethics that mandates truthfulness in their representation, but the question of whether lawyers lie about settlements is complex. It hinges on understanding the intricate balance lawyers must maintain between advocating for their clients and adhering to legal and ethical standards. Settlement discussions are strategic in nature, where attorneys leverage various aspects of the case to reach an agreement that serves their client’s interests.

It is generally against the professional rules for lawyers to misrepresent facts or law to the court or to the other parties involved. When it comes to personal injury cases and their settlements, they may not fabricate or intentionally misstate details about the settlement offer. However, they are permitted to employ certain negotiation tactics to advance their client’s position, which can sometimes involve withholding certain information or emphasizing others. It’s essential to distinguish between dishonesty and negotiation strategy in this context, as the latter is a legitimate part of legal practice.

There are checks and balances in place to discourage and penalize dishonest conduct. Lawyers found to be lying about settlements can face disciplinary action from their state bar association, including sanctions, suspension, or disbarment. Additionally, settlement agreements typically undergo judicial review before finalization, providing another layer of oversight. Nonetheless, the perception that lawyers may be dishonest about settlements persists and underscores the importance of transparency and trust in the attorney-client relationship.

Ethical Considerations for Lawyers

Lawyers are bound by a code of ethics that governs their professional conduct. Central to this is the manner in which they manage the attorney-client relationship and carry out their duty to provide honest representation.

Attorney Client Relationship

The attorney-client relationship is one of trust and confidentiality. An experienced personal injury attorney knows they have a responsibility to maintain their clients’ confidences and act in their best interests at all times. This relationship is fundamental to the legal system and is protected by a range of ethical rules. A lawyer must not disclose information relating to the representation unless the client gives informed consent.

Confidentiality: A pillar of the attorney-client relationship is the duty of confidentiality, which compels lawyers to protect sensitive client information.

Confidence: Lawyers must foster clients’ trust by offering clear guidance and support throughout the legal process.

Fiduciary Duty: This legal and ethical obligation requires lawyers to act in the best interest of their clients, placing the clients’ interests above their own.

Duty to Provide Honest Representation

Lawyers are required to represent their clients honestly and to the best of their ability. Honesty in representation includes a prohibition against making false statements of fact or law to the court or to opposing parties.

Truthfulness: When dealing with the court or any third party, lawyers are expected to be truthful and honest.

Advocacy: While advocating for a client, a lawyer must not misrepresent facts or legal authority or create false evidence.

Settlement Negotiations: During settlement negotiations, lawyers must navigate the fine line between advocacy and the prohibition of dishonesty, ensuring that they do not deceive or unfairly manipulate the opposing party or the court.

Understanding Settlement Negotiations

Settlement negotiations are crucial in resolving disputes outside of court. Lawyers act as negotiators to reach a settlement that serves the interests of their clients, while insurance companies employ various strategies to protect their financial interests.

Role of Lawyers in Negotiations

Lawyers play a central role in settlement negotiations. They must possess a deep understanding of the law, the facts of the case, and their client’s goals. A lawyer’s responsibilities include:

Evaluating the case: Assessing its strengths and weaknesses to determine a fair settlement range.

Advocacy: Arguing effectively for a settlement that is in the best interest of their client.

Advising the client: Presenting the options and providing guidance on the risks and benefits of accepting a settlement.

During negotiations, an Aurora personal injury lawyer is bound by ethical rules. They must act in good faith and not misrepresent facts or laws, but are allowed to engage in puffery or advocate for the most favorable interpretation of the facts for their client. Most personal injury attorneys do so each and every time.

Insurance Company Tactics

Insurance companies often have their own approaches during settlement negotiations. Their tactics can include:

Initial low offers: Proposing a settlement amount lower than what might be considered fair.

Delaying tactics: Prolonging negotiations to pressure claimants into accepting lower settlements.

Disputing claims: Questioning the validity of the claim or the extent of damages to minimize payout.

Despite these strategies, an insurance company typically aims to avoid the expense and uncertainty of a trial by negotiating a settlement they deem fair and reasonable, given the specifics of the case. Dealing with insurance companies requires a strategic approach to ensure a fair settlement that adequately compensates the claimant.

Factors Influencing Settlement Amounts

Settlement amounts in legal cases are influenced by a variety of factors. Understanding the determinants that influence these figures is crucial for attorneys and their clients.

Determining Settlement Value

The settlement value in a legal case is primarily influenced by hard numbers that can be documented and proved in court. Such numbers may include:

Medical expenses: Past, present, and projected future medical treatment costs.

Lost wages: Income lost from not being able to work, both present and anticipated future earnings.

Property damage: The cost of repairing or replacing damaged property.

Pain and suffering: This is more subjective, but it often reflects the severity of the injury and the impact on the individual’s quality of life.

Punitive damages: These are intended to punish the wrongdoer and are added onto compensatory damages.

Evidence and documentation significantly impact the settlement value. The stronger and more compelling the evidence, the more likely the settlement will reflect the true cost of the damages incurred.

Client Expectations vs. Reality

Clients often have a preconceived notion of the value of their case based on various factors including stories from acquaintances or media reports of other cases. These expectations might not always align with the reality due to the unique circumstances of their individual case. The actual settlement a client might receive can be influenced by:

Liability: How clearly they can prove the other party is at fault.

Insurance limits: The maximum amount the insurance policy will pay out can cap the settlement money.

Defendant’s assets: The defendant’s ability to pay, in case insurance doesn’t cover all the damages.

Legal precedents: How similar cases were previously settled can set expectations for current cases.

It is the role of the attorney to bridge the gap between a client’s expectations and the reality of legal proceedings, negotiating a settlement that accurately reflects the damages suffered while managing their client’s expectations.

Legal Boundaries and Misrepresentation

Legal professionals are bound by strict rules that define the extent to which they can represent and negotiate settlements. Misrepresentation can lead to serious legal and professional consequences.

Consequences of Deception

Deceptive practices in legal settlements can result in multiple adverse outcomes, including:

Civil Penalties: The offended party may seek restitution or damages through a civil lawsuit against the deceiving attorney.

Criminal Charges: In certain jurisdictions, egregious forms of deception might lead to criminal fraud charges.

Misconduct and Professional Ethics

Lawyers are regulated by professional ethical standards which include:

Bar Association Sanctions: These sanctions can range from reprimands to disbarment, depending on the severity of the misconduct.

Mandatory Reporting: Colleagues have a duty to report unethical behavior, potentially leading to investigations by the ethics board.

The Role of Personal Injury Lawyers

Personal injury lawyers play a crucial role in the legal system by representing clients who have been injured due to the negligence of others. The primary goal of a Naperville injury lawyer from Mike Agruss Law is to ensure that clients receive fair compensation for their injuries.

Maximizing Client Compensation

They are skilled in negotiating with insurance companies and opposing counsel to achieve the best possible settlement for their clients. Mike Agruss Law has a reputation for vigorously advocating on behalf of their clients to ensure they are adequately compensated for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

We will conduct thorough case evaluations to determine the extent of injury and associated costs. Then, we develop tailored strategies to maximize compensation, considering the specific circumstances of each case.

Specialization and Expertise

Our personal injury lawyers specialize in a wide array of cases, such as car accidents, medical malpractice, and workplace injuries. Their expertise is fundamental in navigating the complexities of personal injury law and increasing the likelihood of a successful outcome.

As such, we maintain a deep understanding of state and federal personal injury laws. The professionals at our law office also keep abreast of legal precedents and advancements in personal injury law to enhance their effectiveness in court and negotiations..

Selecting the Right Lawyer for Settlements

Choosing the right legal representative is crucial when seeking a settlement. Experience, reputation, and compatibility are key factors that influence the outcome.

Evaluating Legal Representation

When assessing attorneys for settlement cases, it’s important to consider their track record and areas of expertise. Mike Agruss Law should be evaluated on our history of handling similar cases and its success rate in securing favorable settlements for its clients.

Experience: Look for a lawyer with a solid background in settlement negotiations.

Specialization: Ensure the attorney specializes in the area relevant to your case.

Reputation: Consider the attorney’s standing in the legal community and reviews from past clients.

Questions to Ask a Potential Attorney

Before retaining an attorney, it is advisable to have a clear understanding of their approach and how they manage settlement negotiations.

  1. Case Handling:
    • How many cases like mine have you handled?
    • What were the outcomes of those cases?
    • How can I know for sure I will get full compensation for my damages and serious injuries?
    • Do you have a legal obligation to tell me about every detail of my case?
  2. Communication:
    • How will you keep me informed about my case?
    • What is your policy on responding to calls or emails?
    • How quickly will you tell me about the initial settlement offer?
  3. Attorney’s Fees:
    • Do you work on a contingency fee basis?
    • Can I get a free case evaluation?
    • What other costs might I incur during the process?

By thoroughly vetting potential legal counsel using these criteria, you’re able to increase the likelihood of securing a lawyer who will competently navigate the complexities of settlement negotiations, while ensuring they have the legal ethics required for you to place your trust in them.

When you select an attorney from our law firm, you can feel at ease that you’ve chosen the right representation. We encourage accident victims to book a free consultation in order to learn more.

Ask us any questions you may have in order to feel more at peace with us throughout the settlement process. Let Mike Agruss Law pursue compensation on your behalf.

Submitted Comments

No Comments submitted yet. Sharing your story will help others!

We are listening

We will respond to you at lightning speed. All of your information will be kept confidential.

Form successfully submitted!