Skip to content

Not Happy With Settlement Offer: How to Reject It

Michael Agruss

Written and Reviewed by Michael Agruss

  • Managing Partner and Personal Injury Lawyer at Mike Agruss Law.
  • Over 20 years of experience in Personal Injury.
  • Over 8000+ consumer rights cases settled.
  • Graduated from the University of Illinois Chicago School of Law: Juris Doctor, 2004.

In the world of legal settlements, receiving an initial offer that doesn’t meet expectations is a common scenario. It’s crucial for individuals to understand that an offer is just the beginning of negotiations and not the final resolution. When the compensation proposed by the insurance company or opposing party falls short, knowing the right steps to effectively counter can make a significant difference in the outcome of a claim.

Rejecting a settlement offer requires a strategic approach that includes a clear presentation of evidence and an articulate explanation of why the offer is inadequate. Crafting a counteroffer involves not only stating the amount one deems appropriate but also providing justifications for this figure, which may encompass medical expenses, lost wages, and other damages sustained. Being informed about the negotiation process empowers individuals to advocate for the compensation they rightfully deserve.

Two Persons Shaking Hand

Understanding Settlement Offers

When faced with a settlement offer, it is crucial to comprehend its components and the function of insurance adjusters. This understanding ensures one is equipped to respond effectively if the offer does not meet expectations of fair compensation.

Components of a Settlement Offer

A settlement offer typically outlines the amount proposed by the insurance company to resolve a claim. It includes:

Total Payment: The lump sum the insurer is willing to pay.

Damages Covered: Itemizes which damages are covered, such as property damage, medical expenses, and any lost wages.

Liability: Sometimes it states the insurer’s stance on their policyholder’s liability.

Terms and Conditions: Any conditions that the claimant must agree to as part of the acceptance of the offer.

Understanding the initial offer is essential because it sets the stage for negotiations. A claimant, the person who made the insurance claim, should review this offer closely. You’ll need to evaluate whether it provides fair compensation for their losses.

Role of Insurance Adjusters

Insurance adjusters play a pivotal role in the settlement process. They:

Assess the claim: Insurance adjusters investigate the incident to determine the extent of the insurer’s liability.

Determine offer amounts: They calculate the initial offer based on the policy details, the damages, and the insured’s liability.

Negotiate settlements: Claims adjusters handle negotiations if the claimant counters the initial offer.

Insurance adjusters are tasked with minimizing the financial exposure of the insurer while also closing claims efficiently. As such, their initial offers might not always reflect the fair compensation that a claimant may be entitled to. As the claimant, it is within your right to reject an initial offer if it is insufficient and does not fully cover the losses incurred from the incident.

Evaluating Your Settlement Offer

When presented with a settlement offer in a personal injury claim, taking the time to carefully evaluate the offer is crucial to ensure it meets the damages incurred. This evaluation should include assessing fair compensation and calculating medical expenses to make an informed decision regarding the settlement’s adequacy.

Assessing Fair Compensation

One should measure the settlement offer against the holistic impact of the personal injury. Fair compensation includes not only immediate financial costs but also non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, and lost earning capacity. Key factors to consider are:

  • Extent of the injury and long-term effects
  • Impact on quality of life
  • Future prognosis and any potential for ongoing care or treatment

By examining these elements, you can determine whether the settlement proposal truly addresses the full scope of the personal injury.

Calculating Medical Expenses

An accurate calculation of medical expenses is essential. Medical expenses should cover:

  • Past, present, and estimated future medical bills
  • Costs for physical rehabilitation
  • Any expected surgeries or medical interventions

The calculation must be based on actual costs and credible estimates to ensure that all health-related financial needs resulting from the personal injury are fully accounted for in the settlement offer.

The Art of Negotiation

Navigating settlement negotiations requires skill and strategy, especially after receiving a low initial offer. It is essential to understand the mechanisms of the insurance industry and remain focused on the goal of securing fair compensation.

Negotiating with the Insurance Adjuster

When engaging with an insurance adjuster, one must be prepared and knowledgeable about the details of the case. They should clearly communicate their dissatisfaction with the initial settlement offer and provide a comprehensive response backed by evidence. It is crucial to remain polite yet assertive, ensuring that the adjuster understands that the offer does not meet the claimant’s needs for fair compensation.

Communicate specific reasons for rejection, meaning you can and should list and explain why the offer is inadequate. In your efforts in doing so, it is a good idea to prepare documentation such as medical records and bills to substantiate claims. Also, be sure you respond in a timely and organized manner.

Strategies for a Better Offer

Developing effective strategies can lead to a more favorable settlement agreement. One must be tactical when presenting their counteroffer:

  1. Know the Worth: They should have a clear understanding of what constitutes fair compensation, which may involve consulting a personal injury attorney from Mike Agruss Law.
  2. Adjuster’s Motivation: Recognize the adjuster’s motivation to settle quickly and use this to leverage a better offer.
  3. Prepare to Walk Away: Be ready to decline inadequate offers and signal a willingness to go to court if necessary.

To increase the strength of your position, use objective evidence. Ground arguments in factual data, not your emotions. Privately, set a minimum acceptable amount. Decide on the lowest acceptable settlement in advance. By remaining composed and steadfast during the negotiation, you are able to shift the power balance in your favor, increasing the likelihood of the insurance company presenting a more reasonable offer.

When to Involve a Personal Injury Attorney From Mike Agruss Law

In the aftermath of an injury, securing a fair settlement offer may be a complex process. The involvement of a Chicago personal injury lawyer can be crucial to navigate the legal landscape and ensure one’s rights are fully represented.

Benefits of Legal Representation

Personal injury attorneys specialize in advocating for their clients’ rights to fair compensation. They bring a wealth of experience to the table, having dealt with various personal injury cases. A skilled attorney from Mike Agruss Law knows the intricacies of negotiation and understands how to present a well-substantiated case that accurately reflects the client’s damages and losses.

Expertise: Personal injury attorneys offer expert advice and can formulate a strategic response to settlement offers.

Negotiation Skills: We possess the negotiation skills necessary to counter lowball offers and work towards maximizing compensation.

Legal Knowledge: Our in-depth knowledge of legal procedures and statutes enables them to protect clients’ interests effectively.

Resource Accessibility: Attorneys have access to resources, including expert witnesses and investigative tools, that can strengthen a claim.

Finding the Right Attorney for Your Case

Choosing the right Naperville injury lawyer is pivotal for the outcome of one’s case. It involves careful consideration of the attorney’s track record, expertise in relevant injury cases, and their ability to communicate and connect with the client.

Reputation & Experience: Research the attorney’s previous cases and seek testimonials from past clients.

Specialization: Verify that the attorney has experience with cases similar to yours.

Communication: Assess the attorney’s willingness to explain legal options and answer questions.

A deliberate selection process can lead to a legal partnership that not only aligns with the client’s needs but also works assiduously towards obtaining fair compensation for the injuries and losses incurred.

Legal Actions in Illinois

When a settlement offer for a personal injury claim in Illinois fails to cover medical bills and related losses, the injured party can explore further legal options.

Understanding Illinois Law on Personal Injury Claims

Under Illinois law, individuals who have suffered harm due to someone else’s negligence have the right to pursue a personal injury claim. Illinois operates under a modified comparative negligence system, which means that the claimant’s ability to recover damages may be reduced by their own percentage of fault. Nonetheless, if a settlement offer does not suffice—especially when it doesn’t adequately address expenses such as medical bills—one has the legal standing to reject the offer and seek a more just compensation through the courts.

Filing a Lawsuit in Illinois

If a settlement offer is rejected, filing a lawsuit might be the next step. In Illinois, the statute of limitations for personal injury cases generally gives an individual two years from the date of injury to commence a lawsuit. It’s crucial to file the lawsuit within this time frame to avoid forfeiting the right to legal redress. Once a lawsuit is filed, the case might be settled before trial or proceed to a court hearing, where the compensation will be determined based on the evidence presented.

What Mike Agruss Law Can Do For You

When dealing with insurance claims, it can be a daunting experience to negotiate with an insurance company, especially when the initial settlement offer falls short of covering your losses or damages. This is where Mike Agruss Law can be an invaluable ally. With a team of experienced attorneys, Mike Agruss Law is dedicated to ensuring that clients receive the compensation they deserve.

Insurance companies are often motivated by profit margins and may attempt to minimize the amount they pay out on claims. They count on the fact that many policyholders are not fully aware of their rights or the true value of their claims. Mike Agruss Law steps in to level the playing field. By advocating on your behalf, the attorneys at Mike Agruss Law can help navigate the complex process of insurance claims, providing expertise and support every step of the way.

The first course of action that an Aurora personal injury lawyer will take is to thoroughly review your insurance policy and the details of your case. Understanding the nuances of your coverage and the extent of your damages or injuries is crucial in building a strong argument for a higher settlement. Our attorneys will gather all necessary evidence, including medical records, repair estimates, and any other documentation that supports your claim.

Armed with this information, Mike Agruss Law will communicate directly with the insurance company on your behalf. Effective negotiation is an art, our attorneys are skilled negotiators who know how to present your case in the most compelling way. We will counter lowball offers with facts and figures that justify a more substantial settlement, and they will not shy away from tough negotiations.

If the insurance company remains uncooperative, Mike Agruss Law is prepared to take legal action. The prospect of litigation can often motivate an insurer to offer a fair settlement rather than face the uncertainty and expense of a trial. However, if your case does go to court, you can be confident that Mike Agruss Law will fight tenaciously for your interests.

Throughout the process, Mike Agruss Law maintains open communication with their clients, ensuring that you are informed and involved in the decision-making process. Our goal is not just to secure a better settlement offer but also to provide peace of mind and a sense of empowerment.

Submitted Comments

No Comments submitted yet. Sharing your story will help others!

We are listening

We will respond to you at lightning speed. All of your information will be kept confidential.

Form successfully submitted!