Skip to content

American Legal Recovery

Michael Agruss

Written and Reviewed by Michael Agruss

  • Managing Partner and Personal Injury Lawyer at Mike Agruss Law.
  • Over 20 years of experience in Personal Injury.
  • Over 8000+ consumer rights cases settled.
  • Graduated from the University of Illinois Chicago School of Law: Juris Doctor, 2004.


Debt collectors like American Legal Recovery cannot harass you over a debt. You have rights under the law, and we will stop the harassment once and for all.

THE BEST PART IS…

If American Legal Recovery violated the law, you will get money damages and they will pay your attorney’s fees and costs. You won’t owe us a dime for our services. Plus, some of our clients also receive debt relief and cleaned-up credit reports. You have nothing to lose! Call us today at 888-572-0176 for a free consultation.

Who is American Legal Recovery?

American Legal Recovery is a collection agency based in Jacksonville, Florida. Minimal public information is available about the agency and it is not recognized by the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

American Legal Recovery’s Address, Phone Number, and Contact Information

American Legal Recovery is located at 2627 Spring Park Road, Jacksonville, FL 32207. The main telephone number is 904-399-3058.

Phone Numbers Used by American Legal Recovery

Like many debt collection agencies, American Legal Recovery may use many different phone numbers to contact debtors. Here is one phone number American Legal Recovery may be calling you from:

  • 904-399-3058

American Legal Recovery Complaints

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) is a federal law that applies to everyone in the United States. In other words, everyone is protected under the FDCPA, and this Act is a laundry list of what debt collectors can and cannot do while collecting a debt, as well as things they must do while collecting debt. If American Legal Recovery is harassing you over a debt, you have rights under the FDCPA.

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) protects you from robocalls, which are those annoying, automated, recorded calls that computers make all day long. You can tell it’s a robocall because either no one responds on the other end of the line, or there is a delay when you pick up the phone before a live person responds. You can receive $500 per call if American Legal Recovery violates the TCPA. Have you received a message from this agency that sounds pre-recorded or cut-off at the beginning or end? These are tell-tale signs that the message is pre-recorded, and if you have these messages on your cell phone, you may have a TCPA case against the agency.

The Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA) protects electronic payments that are deducted from bank accounts. If American Legal Recovery took unauthorized deductions from your bank account, you may have an EFTA claim against the agency. American Legal Recovery, like most collection agencies, wants to set up recurring payments from consumers; imagine how much money it can earn if hundreds, even thousands, of consumers electronically pay them $50 – $100 or more per month. If you agreed to this type of reoccurring payment, the agency must follow certain steps to comply with the EFTA. Did American Legal Recovery continue to take electronic payments after you told them to stop? Did they take more money from your checking account than you agreed to?  If so, we can discuss your rights and a potential case under the EFTA.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) works to ensure that no information reported to your credit report is false. In essence, it gives you the right to dispute those inaccuracies that you find on your credit report. We’ve handled many cases in which a debt collection agency reported debt on a consumer’s credit report to obtain leverage over the consumer. If American Legal Recovery is on your credit report, they may tell you that they’ll remove the debt from your credit report if you pay it; this is commonly known as “pay for delete.” If the original creditor is on your report rather than the debt collector, and you pay off the debt, both entities should accurately report this on your credit report.

Several states also have laws to provide their citizens an additional layer of protection. For example, if you live in California, Florida, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Texas, or Wisconsin, you may be able to add a state-law claim to your federal law claim above. North Carolina, for example, has one of the most consumer-friendly statutes in the country: if you live in NC and are harassed over a debt, you may receive $500 – $4,000 in damages per violation. We work with a local counsel in NC and our NC clients have received some great results in debt collection harassment cases. If you live in North Carolina and are being harassed by a debt collector, you have the leverage to obtain a great settlement.

How do we Use the Law to Help You?

We will use state and federal laws to immediately stop American Legal Recovery’s debt collection. We will send a cease-and-desist letter to stop the harassment today, and if American Legal Recovery violates the FDCPA, EFTA, FCRA, or any state law, you may be entitled to money damages. For example, under the FDCPA, you may receive up to $1,000 in damages plus actual damages. The FDCPA also has a fee-shift provision, which means the debt collector will pay your attorney’s fees and costs. If you have a TCPA case against the agency, we will handle it based on a contingency fee and you won’t pay us a dime unless you win.

THAT’S NOT ALL…

We have helped thousands of consumers stop phone calls. We know how to stop the harassment and get you money damages. Once again: you will not pay us a dime for our services. We will help you based on a fee-shift provision and/or contingency fee, and the debt collector will pay your attorney’s fees and costs.

What if American Legal Recovery is on my Credit Report?

Based on our experience, some debt collectors may credit-report, which means one may mark your credit report with the debt they are trying to collect. In addition to or instead of the debt collector, the original creditor may also be on your credit report in a separate entry, and it’s important to properly identify these entities because you will want both to update your credit report if or when you pay off the debt.

THE GOOD NEWS IS…

If American Legal Recovery is on your credit report, we can help you dispute it. Mistakes on your credit report can be very costly: along with causing you to pay higher interest rates, you may be denied credit, insurance, a rental home, a loan, or even a job because of these mistakes. Some mistakes may include someone else’s information on your credit report, inaccurate public records, stale collection accounts, or even being a victim of identity theft. If you have a mistake on your credit report, there is a process to dispute it, and my office will help you obtain your credit report and dispute any inaccurate information.

REMEMBER…

If a credit reporting agency violates its obligations under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), you may be entitled to statutory damages up to $1,000, and the credit reporting agency will be required to fix the error. The FCRA also has a fee-shift provision, which means the credit reporting agency will pay your attorney’s fees and costs. You won’t owe us a dime for our services. We have helped hundreds of consumers fix inaccurate information on their credit reports, and we’re ready to help you, too.

What Our Clients Say About Us

Mike Agruss Law has over 950 outstanding client reviews through Yotpo, an A+ BBB rating, and over 130 five-star reviews on Google. Here’s what some of our clients have to say about us:

“Michael Agruss handled two settlements for me with great results and he handled them quickly. He also settled my sister’s case quickly and now her debt is clear. I highly recommend Michael.”

“Mike Agruss Law was very helpful, they helped me solve my case regarding the unwanted calls. I would highly recommend them. Thank you very much Mike Agruss!”

“Mike Agruss Law was very helpful to me and my veteran father! We were harassed daily and even called names for a loan that was worthless! Agruss stepped in and not only did they stop harassing, they stopped calling altogether!! Even settled it so I was paid back for the problems they caused!”

Can American Legal Recovery Sue Me?

Although anyone can sue anyone for any reason, we have not seen American Legal Recovery sue consumers, and it’s likely that the agency does not sue because they don’t always own the debt they are attempting to collect, and would also need to hire a lawyer, or use in-house counsel, to file a lawsuit. It’s also likely that the agency collects debt throughout the country, and it would be quite difficult to have lawyers, or a law firm, licensed in every state. However, there are collection agencies that do sue consumers; for example, Midland Credit Management is one of the largest junk-debt buyers, and it also collects and sues on debt. Still, it is less likely for a debt collector to sue you than for an original creditor to hire a lawyer or collection firm to sue you. If American Legal Recovery has threatened to sue you, contact Mike Agruss Law as soon as possible.

Can American Legal Recovery Garnish my Wages?

No, unless they have a judgment. If American Legal Recovery has not sued you, then the agency cannot get a judgment. Barring limited situations (usually involving debts owed to the government for student loans, taxes, etc.), a company must have a judgment in order to garnish someone’s wages. In short, we have not seen this agency file a lawsuit against a consumer, so the agency cannot garnish your wages, minus the exceptions listed above. If American Legal Recovery has threatened to garnish your wages, contact our office right away.

American Legal Recovery Settlement

If you want to settle a debt with American Legal Recovery, ask yourself these questions first:

  1. Do I really owe this debt?
  2. Is this debt within the statute of limitations?
  3. Is this debt on my credit report?
  4. If I pay this debt, will American Legal Recovery remove it from my credit report?
  5. If I pay this debt, will the original creditor remove it from my credit report?
  6. If I pay this debt, will I receive confirmation in writing from American Legal Recovery for the payment and settlement terms?

These are not the only things to consider when dealing with debt collectors. We are here to help you answer the questions above, and much more. Whether it’s harassment, settlement, pay-for-delete, or any other legal issue with American Legal Recovery, we at Mike Agruss Law are here to help you.

Top Debt Collection Violations

Debt collection laws provide a laundry list of what collectors can and cannot do while collecting a debt. Based on our years of experience handling thousands of debt collection harassment cases, here’s what collection agencies most often do to violate the law:

  1. Called you about a debt you do not owe.
  2. Called you at work after you told them you cannot receive calls at work.
  3. Left you a message without identifying the company’s name.
  4. Left you a message without disclosing that the call is from a debt collector.
  5. Called third parties (family, friends, coworkers, or neighbors) even though the collection agency knows your contact information.
  6. Disclosed to a third party (family, friends, coworkers, or neighbors) that you owe a debt.
  7. Contacted you after you said to stop calling.
  8. Threatened you with legal action (such as a lawsuit or wage garnishment).
  9. Called you before 8:00 AM or after 9:00 PM.
  10. Continued to call you after you have told the collector you cannot pay the debt.
  11. Communicated (phone or letter) with you after you filed for bankruptcy.
  12. Failed to mark the debt on your credit report as disputed after you disputed the debt.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Do I have to pay your fees and costs for helping me with my consumer rights case? No. We handle consumer rights cases based on a fee-shift provision and/or a contingency fee. That means either the other side pays your fees and costs, or we take a percentage of your recovery. Whether it’s a fee-shift case or a contingency-fee case, we don’t get paid unless you get paid, and you’ll never owe us a penny for our time.

  2. What are the damages I can get under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act? If a collection agency violates any section of the FDCPA, you are entitled to damages up to $1,000.00. You may also be entitled to actual damages if the violation caused you out-of-pocket expenses. For example, if a collection agency threatens you with legal action to induce you to pay the debt, you may be able to get your payment back as actual damages.

  3. What are the damages under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act? You can get $500 per robocall, or $1,500 per robocall if the robocalls were willful. In any type of settlement, Defendants often pay much less than $500 per call. However, if there are 50 calls at issue, even at $250 per call, your case could settle for $12,500.00.

  4. What type of debt is covered under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act? Only consumer debt, such as personal, family, and household debts. For example, the money you owe on a personal credit card, an auto loan, a medical bill, or a utility bill. The FDCPA does not cover debts you incurred to run a business, or debts regarding unpaid taxes, or traffic tickets.

  5. Does the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act apply to banks or credit card companies? No. Only third-party debt collectors are bound by the FDCPA. Original creditors, such as banks and credit card companies, are not bound by the FDCPA.

  6. Are there state laws that protect me from original creditors? Yes! Several states also have laws that provide their citizens an additional layer of protection. If you live in California, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, North Carolina, Nevada, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Texas, or Wisconsin, you have additional state-law rights.

  7. Are mistakes on credit reports common? Yes! Are you one of the 40 million Americans who have a mistake on their credit report? Mistakes on your credit report can be very costly.  Along with causing you to pay higher interest rates, you may be denied credit, insurance, a rental home, a loan, or even a job because of these mistakes. Some mistakes may include someone else’s information on your credit report, inaccurate public records, stale collection accounts, or maybe you were a victim of identity theft.

  8. What do I do if I have a mistake on my credit report? If you have a mistake on your credit report, there is a process to dispute them. My office will help you pull your credit report and dispute any inaccurate information. If a credit reporting agency violates its obligations under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), you may be entitled to statutory damages up to $1,000.00, plus the credit reporting agency will be required to fix the error.  The FCRA also has a fee-shift provision, which means the credit reporting agency pays your attorney’s fees and costs. Therefore, you will not pay me a penny for my time. To speed up the process, please get a free copy of your credit report at www.annualcreditreport.com. You can also learn more about the FCRA and your rights at http://www.agrussconsumerlaw.com/practices/common-credit-report-errors/

Share your Complaints against American Legal Recovery Below

We encourage you to post your complaints about American Legal Recovery. Sharing your complaints against this agency can help other consumers understand what to do when this company starts calling. Sharing your experience may help someone else!

HERE’S THE DEAL!

If you are being harassed by American Legal Recovery over a debt, you may be entitled to money damages – up to $1,000 for harassment, and $500 – $1,500 for illegal robocalls. Under state and federal laws, we will help you based on a fee-shift provision and/or contingency fee, which means the debt collector pays your attorney’s fees and costs. You won’t owe us a dime for our services. We have settled thousands of debt collection harassment cases, and we’re prepared to help you, too. Contact Mike Agruss Law at 888-572-0176 to stop the harassment once and for all.

Submitted Comments

Debbie
4 years ago
I keep getting harassing phone calls from a recording that states press one or call number back. I have received nothing in writing. I was scammed a few years ago, I don't give out any information. If there is a debt, they should write and provide all information. I have talked to my local police and BBB as well. They got a letter sent to them as well.
Lori
4 years ago
Contacted repeatedly by American Legal Recovery, even telling me they are from _____ County Clerk of Courts office (6/5/2020) when the courts were closed. The caller said someone would be at my house in 35 min to serve me with a criminal fraud claim and civil claim for a past debt.
danny
4 years ago
called about a debt that has been payed off requesting make more payment after i paid it off
Eboni
3 years ago
Has called about a pay day loan debt from a place I've never heard of. Threatened to freeze my accounts and garnish my wages.
Corinna
2 years ago
I was contacted by debt company who threatened me with garnishment if I did not pay debt today, refused to give me any written form of debt owed, told me they will just file with courts and that would be my written proof of debt
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
Hi Corinna. Debt collectors cannot threaten you with legal action unless they plan on following through. They do have to provide you with a debt verification letter if you request it--preferably with a certified letter. I would like to speak with you about the calls, give me a call at 312 300 5996. Thanks, Mike
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
Hi Eboni. Debt collectors like to threaten consumers, especially with legal action, and fortunately, consumers are protected by the law and thus you cannot have your wages garnished without a court order. While some debt collectors do follow through, many do not. I would be happy to speak with you about the calls and see how I can help you to get this resolved. I am going to call you and we can discuss how. Thanks, Mike
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
Hello Danny. Do you have the proof of the final payment? If you do, you can send it over to my office and I will look at it and contact you about how to get American Legal Recovery to accept your proof and leave you alone. Thanks, Mike
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
HI Lori. Debt collectors like to do this kind of thing to scare consumers into paying. It is illegal, however, to pretend to be the law and threaten you. I'm going to reach out to you to discuss this further and see what options you have in this situation. Thanks, Mike
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
Hi Debbie. You can request that American Legal Recovery send you a debt verification letter. This should preferably be done through a certified letter. If you need assistance with this, give me a call and we can chat about how to do this. Thanks, Mike
Jennifer
2 years ago
Was contacted by American Legal Recovery and was told I was I would be sued over a closed debt from 2015 for some payday loan I don’t remember getting. When I asked for proof of the debt they assumed I didn’t wanna do anything about it then had the Bernalillo County Metro court contact me twice trying to setup a court date with the judge. Then they said if I didn’t setup a payment arrangement I was going to have a hold placed on my drivers license.
Jennifer
2 years ago
They’ve contacted me again. This time they’ve left a voicemail that stated: ““This message is intended for Jennifer Weiss there was a judgment complaint being filled with your name and Social Security number attached please press one to talk to a representative or contact us at 844-385-4640…”
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
Hi Jennifer. I can understand being nervous about these calls, they do sound official and frightening. But, keep in mind that many times these are empty threats by debt collectors. Have you been officially served any papers from American Legal Recovery about this debt? Give me a call at 312 300 5996 and we can discuss this in more detail. Thanks, Mike
Michael Agruss
2 years ago
Hi Jennifer. I'm going to give you a call to discuss this situation with you in a free, no-obligation consultation. We can go over your rights, your options, and the law and also work on a plan for your next steps. You can also contact me sooner at 312 300 5996. Thanks, Mike
Carolyn
1 year ago
I have been getting call for years for a Chris adam Humenik. I have stated many times that no one by that name is at that number and I have had the number for over ten years. I have ask at least 20 time to remove my number and I get call almost every day and sometimes 3 and 4 times a day. This has cause me undo stress and I do not want to go through the hassel of changing my number on everything. What option do I have? I have save the last 15 calls on my answering machine. Thank you
Phi
1 year ago
Inquiry about American Legal Recovery harassment\'s case, they contact me about my mother\'s debt and kept on asking me to pay for her debts/legal fees/court fees every single day since July 2022. I repeatedly told them I have no money to pay for these dues and I am now 40k in credit card debts in paying these debts but they won\'t stop contacting me. Also, I asked them to provide me all the case details but they never sent me these details to verifying. How can I make them stop contacting me?
Denise
12 months ago
CONTINUED HARASSING PHONE CALL AND MAKING THREATS AFTER TELLING THEM IT IS THE WRONG PHONE NUMBER
Naomi
8 months ago
For the last two years I have been dealing with American Legal Recovery and Wright & Payne regarding pay day loans from 14 years ago. I know I took some out at the time, and due to circumstances at the time I do not think all were laid in full. However, in the last two years I have settled 12-15 loans. I unfortunately do not recall from so long ago and do not still have documents myself, but I know I did not take that many pay day loans and not pay them back. This past week I was called about 3 more. Each time I am told there will be garnishment, or that someone is out to serve me if I don’t take care of it right then, so I do. If I actually owe something, I want to take care of it. But this last week they started taking payments out of my checking account I did not authorize. Almost $3000! I’ve disputed with my bank and have tried getting them to explain what is happening and cannot get any answers. Letters of payment received this week have all been incorrect. Amounts, payment dates, and creditors all wrong. One for a creditor I settled and paid on November of 2022. I really don’t think this is legitimate. I wish I questioned this more earlier, but I really don’t know what to do at this point. Nothing shows up on my credit report, so it’s hard to know if there legitimately is something I owe. I have never received a single thing from a creditor or these companies in the mail or via email. Help!?
Jose Antonio
7 months ago
I AM LOOKING FOR SOMEONE WHO CAN COLLECT MONEY AND PROPERTIES FROM MY BAILIFF HIMSELF. I THINK HE IS STEALING.

We are listening

We will respond to you at lightning speed. All of your information will be kept confidential.

Form successfully submitted!